This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeFront Matter
|
5.0 pts
Excellent
Includes title page, table of contents, list of figures, and list of tables.
|
3.75 pts
Adequate
|
2.5 pts
Poor
|
1.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
5.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeIntroduction
|
5.0 pts
Excellent
Explains the problem background and why it is of interest to the IP; introduces the report structure.
|
3.75 pts
Adequate
|
2.5 pts
Poor
|
1.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
5.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeInitial Problem Statement
|
5.0 pts
Excellent
Initial problem statement supplied by the industrial partner.
|
3.75 pts
Adequate
|
2.5 pts
Poor
|
1.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
5.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeBackground Research
|
25.0 pts
Excellent
Uses sources other than the industrial partner; includes public safety, health, and welfare; describes global, cultural, social, environmental, and economic factors that play into the problem; all sources of information are referenced.
|
18.75 pts
Adequate
|
12.5 pts
Poor
|
6.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
25.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeCustomers
|
20.0 pts
Excellent
Identifies customer groups and how the problem affects them; describes their relationship to the industrial partner and their needs.
|
15.0 pts
Adequate
|
10.0 pts
Poor
|
5.0 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
20.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeInterviews
|
15.0 pts
Excellent
Describes who you interviewed/observed and questions asked; documents answers you received and observations.
|
10.75 pts
Adequate
|
7.5 pts
Poor
|
3.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
15.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeValue Propositions
|
10.0 pts
Excellent
Documents how solving the problem will provide value for the customers.
|
7.5 pts
Adequate
|
5.0 pts
Poor
|
2.5 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
10.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeRefined Problem Statement
|
20.0 pts
Excellent
A clear, concise, and accurate problem statement that describes hidden and underlying aspects of the problem.
|
15.0 pts
Adequate
|
10.0 pts
Poor
|
5.0 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
20.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeExisting Solutions and Intellectual Property
|
25.0 pts
Excellent
Describes and evaluates existing devices, products, or services that appear to solve the problem; describes related patents and intellectual property; describes related engineering standards; all information is referenced.
|
18.75 pts
Adequate
|
12.5 pts
Poor
|
6.25 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
25.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeConclusions
|
10.0 pts
Excellent
Summarizes your work and how you will work with your team to create the problem statement.
|
7.5 pts
Adequate
|
5.0 pts
Poor
|
2.5 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
10.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeCitations and Bibliography
|
20.0 pts
Excellent
Includes at least 10 sources; all sources cited in the report body; citations and entries are formatted in IEEE format.
|
15.0 pts
Adequate
|
10.0 pts
Poor
|
5.0 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Not present.
|
|
20.0 pts
|
This criterion is linked to a Learning OutcomeFormat, Spelling, and Grammar
|
20.0 pts
Excellent
Consistent format: font, headings, etc. Few or no grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors.
|
15.0 pts
Adequate
|
10.0 pts
Poor
Significant format inconsistencies or multiple grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors; meaning can still be understood.
|
5.0 pts
Attempted
|
0.0 pts
Missing
Multiple grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors make it difficult to understand the document.
|
|
20.0 pts
|
Total Points: 180.0
|